Advanced Review Guidelines
For Readers
Ratings GuidelinesDoing ARC reads and ALC listens is a great way to support authors and creators. When seeking advance reviews, an author or publisher often puts considerable time and expense into selecting reviewers and sending copies. Creators do it in the hope of building reviews and excitement before release.
Swoonstack is committed to supporting readers, creators and the romance-reading community. We support early reviews and ratings to build buzz, improve a book’s discoverability and help it find the right readers.
We’ve put together these simple guidelines to help readers navigate the etiquette and expectations of advanced reviewing.
1. Don't over-commit
When applying for ARCs and ALCs, check your diary, reading plans and review deadlines beforehand. Only take on what you can realistically finish and review. Sometimes things change and you may no longer be able to meet a commitment; communicate early rather than going silent.
2. Know the deadline and terms
Make sure you know when reviews are due and follow any instructions from the author, publisher or provider. Add ARC/ALC deadlines, sources and notes to your Advanced Review Stacks in Swoonstack to help you keep track.
3. Be honest and kind
Reviews do not have to be positive, but they should never be mean-spirited. Don’t yuck anyone else’s yum: a book that was not for you is not necessarily a bad book. Explain what worked or did not work, because your deal-breaker might be exactly what another reader is looking for. Only review a book you have actually read or listened to, and be transparent if you did not finish it.
4. Disclose your advanced copy
Make it clear when you received a free or advance review copy, and follow the disclosure rules of each platform. Receiving a copy never obliges you to give a positive review.
5. Share your review widely
Where the provider permits it, post your review on as many relevant platforms as you reasonably can, such as retailers, Goodreads, StoryGraph and Swoonstack. Check each platform’s rules and the review embargo or publication date first. Be mindful of spoilers.
6. Know each platform’s rating guidelines
Ratings do not always mean the same thing on different platforms. Check the scale before choosing your stars so your rating reflects what you actually think of the book.
7. Have Fun!
ARC reading and listening shouldn’t feel like a chore – it should be fun and fulfilling.